In the not-so-distant future, Earth faces a dire climate catastrophe, rendering the planet nearly uninhabitable. Junior, portrayed by Paul Mescal, becomes part of a program that mandates him to spend a year living on a space station orbiting Earth. This separation from his wife, Henrietta, played by Saoirse Ronan, leaves her alone on the planet. In an effort to prepare Henrietta for Junior’s absence, Terrance, embodied by Aaron Pierre, an agent from the enigmatic corporate-governmental entity overseeing the program, moves in with the couple. His task is to meticulously record and understand every aspect of their lives and personalities. This documentation is essential because it will be used to create an exact duplicate of Junior, ensuring Henrietta can continue her life as if her husband had never left. The central premise is laden with weighty implications and potential, but Foe, directed by Garth Davis and co-written with Iain Reid, the author of the original novel, grapples with challenges in weaving all of its intriguing elements into a cohesive narrative.
Foe stumbles right from the beginning with an overly explanatory title screen that attempts to provide context about the state of the world and the concept of human replacements. This introduction feels somewhat premature, as the human replacement aspect of the story doesn’t come into play until later, leading to initial confusion. Furthermore, the film’s challenge lies in immersing the audience in yet another near-future world marred by the devastating effects of climate change. Given the current real-world climate crisis, it can be challenging for viewers to engage with yet another portrayal of desolate landscapes and a world in turmoil, as these themes are already all too visible in our own surroundings.
Foe certainly boasts visually stunning elements, including its atmospheric and meticulously designed sets, as well as the impressive costumes worn by the characters. The film also features some moments that artfully play with lighting, evoking comparisons to the visually striking Days of Heaven. However, it’s worth noting that the film might have been more effective if it had forgone the introductory lines of text and instead commenced with a poignant scene featuring Saoirse Ronan’s character, where she is seen crying in the shower, reflecting on new beginnings and the solitude of not being truly seen by the one person who always saw her.
Despite the initial concerns, it’s essential to acknowledge the stellar performances delivered by Saoirse Ronan, Paul Mescal, and Aaron Pierre. Ronan portrays a character quietly enduring suffering, Mescal vividly portrays a character losing his grip on reality, and Pierre brings an air of enjoyment to his role. Whether it’s a scene featuring all three or just one of them on screen, there’s a constant display of sparks and chemistry in all directions. However, the film’s extensive use of extreme close-up shots can become somewhat tiresome. A significant portion of the screen time is spent zoomed in on a single character’s face, often filling the entire screen with their presence for extended periods. While this technique does contribute to a sense of claustrophobia that complements the movie’s small-scale setting, it can also feel excessive and divert attention from the intriguing dynamics that could be unfolding between the characters.
Foe is undeniably a sci-fi film, but it delves into a more intimate and specific subject: the challenges of marrying at a young age. The characters’ awkwardness, which might be attributed to a perceived weak script or peculiar acting choices, could instead be seen as a reflection of Junior and Henrietta’s communication style, reminiscent of teenagers. They appear as a couple who not only struggle to communicate effectively but also grapple with intimacy in their relationship. Their interactions follow a particular pattern, suggesting that, despite seven years together, they remain trapped in a limited understanding of how a couple should behave.
This predicament stems from their decision to marry immediately after school and reside on an isolated farm with no friends or neighbors, depriving them of external feedback and influences on what a healthy relationship should resemble. Their situation is a classic example of a couple struggling to evolve and adapt, and both characters excel in portraying their respective roles in this context.
The intricate dynamics between the three central characters in Foe come to the forefront as the tension, jealousy, and anxiety within their relationships intensify. Junior, engrossed in his own concerns, remains oblivious to the growing issues. Henrietta, having never experienced anything different, struggles to find the strength to address the problems. Terrance, as an outsider with a broader perspective, takes a somewhat detached and amused stance, reveling in the unraveling of this couple.
However, it’s unfortunate that as the film progresses and the major twist unfolds in the final act, the narrative becomes increasingly complex and convoluted, which can leave the overall resolution feeling less than wholly satisfying.
Foe grapples with a multifaceted narrative, combining elements of hard sci-fi and romantic drama. The film’s complexity is evident in the way it navigates the dynamics and resolutions of the characters’ relationships. While the romantic drama aspect could have provided a more emotionally satisfying conclusion on its own, and the pure sci-fi angle could have streamlined the twist, the simultaneous pursuit of both genres can lead to a sense of information overload.
The film’s attempt to balance these various elements can make it challenging to fully appreciate the depth of the relationships and their inherent intrigue. Even with the film’s visually striking and intimate portrayals of the characters, these elements may not receive the attention they truly deserve, given the film’s ambitious scope.
ALSO READ: Halloween Creeps onto the Small Screen – The Birth of a New Horror Universe
Foe certainly has its merits, with a wealth of intriguing ideas and commendable performances from its three lead actors. However, the film’s ambition to encompass multiple genres and themes simultaneously may lead to a sense of overextension, preventing it from fully realizing the potential of its various promises. Despite its strengths, Foe grapples with the challenge of balancing its diverse elements, which could impact the overall cohesiveness of the narrative.
Foe is currently being screened in theaters, offering viewers an opportunity to explore its complex and multi-faceted storytelling.
ALSO READ: Totally Killer Movie Review – 80s Nostalgic Thriller with Time Travel Twists, Horror, and Humor
Ballerina Review – Stunning Visual Feast of Revenge and Redemption
